Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Save (floppy disk) icon #272

Closed
yousifalraheem opened this issue May 27, 2020 · 5 comments · Fixed by #610 or #1792
Closed

Save (floppy disk) icon #272

yousifalraheem opened this issue May 27, 2020 · 5 comments · Fixed by #610 or #1792

Comments

@yousifalraheem
Copy link

Please add an icon representing save. Something similar to the one in fontawesome

@ffes ffes mentioned this issue Dec 17, 2020
@mdo mdo mentioned this issue Dec 28, 2020
mdo added a commit that referenced this issue Dec 28, 2020
- Added window-dock
- Added two symmetry icons (fixes #366)
- Added new stack icon
- Added two speedometer icons (fixes #347)
- Added four save icons (fixes #272)
- Added rulers icon
- Added filled variations for phone-vibrate, mouse, mouse2, mouse3, and four hand icons
- Added several border icons
- Added paint bucket
- Added four new badges (3D, AR, VR, WC)
- Added four lightbulb icons (fixes #323)
- Added eyedropper (fixes #366)
- Added mask icon
mdo added a commit that referenced this issue Dec 29, 2020
- Added window-dock
- Added two symmetry icons (fixes #366)
- Added new stack icon
- Added two speedometer icons (fixes #347)
- Added four save icons (fixes #272)
- Added rulers icon
- Added filled variations for phone-vibrate, mouse, mouse2, mouse3, and four hand icons
- Added several border icons
- Added paint bucket
- Added four new badges (3D, AR, VR, WC)
- Added four lightbulb icons (fixes #323)
- Added eyedropper (fixes #366)
- Added mask icon
- Added two color palette icons (fixes #151)
- Added layer-forward and layer-backward
- Added two eraser icons (fixes #366)
- Added two megaphone icons (fixes #357)
mdo added a commit that referenced this issue Dec 29, 2020
- Added window-dock
- Added two symmetry icons (fixes #366)
- Added new stack icon
- Added two speedometer icons (fixes #347)
- Added four save icons (fixes #272)
- Added rulers icon
- Added filled variations for phone-vibrate, mouse, mouse2, mouse3, and four hand icons
- Added several border icons
- Added paint bucket
- Added four new badges (3D, AR, VR, WC)
- Added four lightbulb icons (fixes #323)
- Added eyedropper (fixes #366)
- Added mask icon
- Added two color palette icons (fixes #151)
- Added layer-forward and layer-backward
- Added two eraser icons (fixes #366)
- Added two megaphone icons (fixes #357)
- Added four push pin icons (fixes #257)
- Added Whatsapp and Telegram social icons (fixes #560, fixes #335)
mdo added a commit that referenced this issue Dec 29, 2020
- Added window-dock
- Added two symmetry icons (fixes #366)
- Added new stack icon
- Added two speedometer icons (fixes #347)
- Added four save icons (fixes #272)
- Added rulers icon
- Added filled variations for phone-vibrate, mouse, mouse2, mouse3, and four hand icons
- Added several border icons
- Added paint bucket
- Added four new badges (3D, AR, VR, WC)
- Added four lightbulb icons (fixes #323)
- Added eyedropper (fixes #366)
- Added mask icon
- Added two color palette icons (fixes #151)
- Added layer-forward and layer-backward
- Added two eraser icons (fixes #366)
- Added two megaphone icons (fixes #357)
- Added four push pin icons (fixes #257)
- Added Whatsapp and Telegram social icons (fixes #560, fixes #335)
mdo added a commit that referenced this issue Dec 29, 2020
- Added window-dock and window-sidebar
- Added two symmetry icons (fixes #366)
- Added new stack icon
- Added two speedometer icons (fixes #347)
- Added four save icons (fixes #272)
- Added rulers icon
- Added filled variations for phone-vibrate, mouse, mouse2, mouse3, and four hand icons
- Added several border icons
- Added paint bucket
- Added four new badges (3D, AR, VR, WC)
- Added four lightbulb icons (fixes #323)
- Added eyedropper (fixes #366)
- Added mask icon
- Added three color palette icons (fixes #151)
- Added layer-forward and layer-backward
- Added two eraser icons (fixes #366)
- Added two megaphone icons (fixes #357)
- Added four push pin icons (fixes #257)
- Added Whatsapp and Telegram social icons (fixes #560, fixes #335)
- Added dotted circle dash, circle plus, square dash, and square plus
mdo added a commit that referenced this issue Jan 2, 2021
- Added window-dock and window-sidebar
- Added two symmetry icons (fixes #366)
- Added new stack icon
- Added two speedometer icons (fixes #347)
- Added four save icons (fixes #272)
- Added rulers icon
- Added filled variations for phone-vibrate, mouse, mouse2, mouse3, and four hand icons
- Added several border icons
- Added paint bucket
- Added four new badges (3D, AR, VR, WC)
- Added four lightbulb icons (fixes #323)
- Added eyedropper (fixes #366)
- Added mask icon
- Added three color palette icons (fixes #151)
- Added layer-forward and layer-backward
- Added two eraser icons (fixes #366)
- Added two megaphone icons (fixes #357)
- Added four push pin icons (fixes #257)
- Added Whatsapp and Telegram social icons (fixes #560, fixes #335)
- Added dotted circle dash, circle plus, square dash, and square plus
@mdo mdo closed this as completed in #610 Jan 5, 2021
mdo added a commit that referenced this issue Jan 5, 2021
- Added window-dock and window-sidebar
- Added two symmetry icons (fixes #366)
- Added new stack icon
- Added two speedometer icons (fixes #347)
- Added four save icons (fixes #272)
- Added rulers icon
- Added filled variations for phone-vibrate, mouse, mouse2, mouse3, and four hand icons
- Added several border icons
- Added paint bucket
- Added four new badges (3D, AR, VR, WC)
- Added four lightbulb icons (fixes #323)
- Added eyedropper (fixes #366)
- Added mask icon
- Added three color palette icons (fixes #151)
- Added layer-forward and layer-backward
- Added two eraser icons (fixes #366)
- Added two megaphone icons (fixes #357)
- Added four push pin icons (fixes #257)
- Added Whatsapp and Telegram social icons (fixes #560, fixes #335)
- Added dotted circle dash, circle plus, square dash, and square plus
@XmlmXmlmX
Copy link

The committed save-icons don't really look like a common save icon:

image

Why not use a well known floppy-disk as suggested in the issues title?

image

@mdo
Copy link
Member

mdo commented Feb 11, 2021

Why not use a well known floppy-disk as suggested in the issues title?

Personally I haven't clicked a floppy disk icon for years—a growing majority of interfaces don't use it and instead opt for download icons. These save icons are reminiscent enough of floppy disks to work well IMO.

@korki43 korki43 mentioned this issue Jan 22, 2022
@samuelstroschein
Copy link

samuelstroschein commented Apr 8, 2022

a growing majority of interfaces don't use it and instead opt for download icons

I am building a web app that modifies files, not downloading them. Using bootstrap's "save" icons which are "download" icons is confusing.

EDIT: giving more context. This is a situation that needs a floppy disk.
image

@shishirraven
Copy link

I agree that "Floppy" icon is most recognized symbol of Save, in situations where a group of Icons are placed together.
The user should be able to easily identify which one is save button.

See the following bar and we had to use to "Cloud Upload" icon, which is not the best for the users to identify easily, even I get confused when I am the developer of the app.

image

The save icons are good but only in case we are downloading some file from the web. But when you are working on an app and saving your work or draft online or working on a electron app, I think floppy is much more relevant.

@scottkuhl
Copy link

I agree that "Floppy" icon is most recognized symbol of Save, in situations where a group of Icons are placed together. The user should be able to easily identify which one is save button.

See the following bar and we had to use to "Cloud Upload" icon, which is not the best for the users to identify easily, even I get confused when I am the developer of the app.

image

The save icons are good but only in case we are downloading some file from the web. But when you are working on an app and saving your work or draft online or working on a electron app, I think floppy is much more relevant.

I agree, it’s strange that the maintainers will not add an additional icon. It makes no sense to dig in on this issue. How many us are still walking around with magnifying glasses in our pockets looking for stuff, but it’s still the search icon. I really wish we could convince the maintainers to add this request. The time it takes to closing multiple issues about this is longer than making the icon.

This one single issue is why I can’t get buy off from my company to use this icon set. So sad.

@claviska claviska mentioned this issue Jul 14, 2022
@mdo mdo mentioned this issue Aug 26, 2023
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Projects
None yet
Development

Successfully merging a pull request may close this issue.

6 participants