Add getter for payload attestation cache #14328

terencechain · 2024-08-09T18:08:22Z

No description provided.

potuz · 2024-08-09T18:27:57Z

beacon-chain/cache/payload_attestation.go

+	if p.root != root {
+		return nil
+	}
+	if uint64(status) >= uint64(len(p.attestations)) {


why not check agains the constant PAYLOAD_INVALID_STATUS?

jihoonsong · 2024-08-12T12:12:48Z

proto/prysm/v1alpha1/cloners.go

@@ -164,3 +164,15 @@ func CopyPayloadAttestationData(data *PayloadAttestationData) *PayloadAttestatio
 		PayloadStatus:   data.PayloadStatus,
 	}
 }
+
+// CopyPayloadAttestation copies the provided PayloadAttestation.
+func CopyPayloadAttestation(a *PayloadAttestation) *PayloadAttestation {


It's not a big of a deal but this can replace L147-L152 with newAttestations[i] = CopyPayloadAttestation(att).

jihoonsong · 2024-08-12T12:23:16Z

These are just typos:

At L77 in cloners.go,
From:
// CopyBeaconBlockEPBS copies the provided CopyBeaconBlockEPBS.
To:
// CopyBeaconBlockEPBS copies the provided BeaconBlockEPBS.
At L91 in cloners.go
From:
// CopyBeaconBlockBodyEPBS copies the provided CopyBeaconBlockBodyEPBS.
To:
// CopyBeaconBlockBodyEPBS copies the provided BeaconBlockBodyEPBS.

* Add getter for payload attestation cache * Check against status * Feedback #1

* Add protos for ePBS except state * Add ePBS beacon state proto * ePBS configuration constants * Helper for Payload Attestation Signing (#13901) * Add ePBS stuff to consensus-types: block * Add testing utility methods to return randomly populated ePBS objects * Add ePBS to state (#13926) * Implement get_ptc This implements a helper to get the ptc committee from a state. It uses the cached beacon committees if possible It also implements a helper to compute the largest power of two of a uint64 and a helper to test for nil payload attestation messages * Add EPBS slashing params * Add ePBS to db (#13971) * Add ePBS to db * Fix GetPayloadTimelinessCommittee to return correct PTC size (#14012) * Change gwei math to primitives package for ePBS state * use Keymanager() in validator client * Add PTC assignment support for Duty endpoint (#14032) * Enable validator client to submit payload attestation message (#14064) * Remove inclusion list from epbs (#14188) * Modify `get_ptc` function to follow the Python spec (#14256) * Modify `get_ptc` function to follow the Python spec * Assign PTC members from the beginning of beacon committee array * Add `remove_flag` and its unit test (#14260) * Add `remove_flag` and its unit test * Add a test case trying to remove a flag that is not set * Ensure epbs state getters & setters check versions (#14276) * Ensure EPBS state getters and setters check versions * Rename to LatestExecutionPayloadHeaderEPBS * Add minimal beacon state * Use slot for latest message in forkchoice (#14279) * Add payload attestation helper functions (#14258) * Add `IndexedPayloadAttestation` container * Add `GetPayloadAttestingIndices` and its unit test * Add `GetIndexedPayloadAttestation` and its unit test * Add `is_valid_indexed_payload_attestation` and its unit test * Create a smaller set of validators for faster unit test * Pass context to `GetPayloadTimelinessCommittee` * Iterate `ValidatorsReadOnly` instead of copying all validators * Use BeaconCommittees helper to get the ptc (#14286) * Allow nodes with and without payload in forkchoice (#14288) * Allow nodes with and without payload in forkchoice This PR takes care of adding nodes to forkchoice that may or may not have a corresponding payload. The rationale is as follows - The node structure is kept almost the same as today. - A zero payload hash is considered as if the node was empty (except for the tree root) - When inserting a node we check what the right parent node would be depending on whether the parent had a payload or not. - For pre-epbs forks all nodes are full, no logic changes except a new steps to gather the parent hash that is needed for block insertion. This PR had to change some core consensus types and interfaces. - It removed the ROBlockEPBS interface and added the corresponding ePBS fields to the ReadOnlyBeaconBlockBody - It moved the setters and getters to epbs dedicated files. It also added a checker for `IsParentFull` on forkchoice that simply checks for the parent hash of the parent node. * review * Read only payload attestation message with Verifier (#14222) * Read only payload attestation message with verifier * Payload attestation tests (#14242) * Payload attestation in verification package * Feedback #1 --------- Co-authored-by: Md Amaan <114795592+Redidacove@users.noreply.github.com> * Broadcast signed execution payload header to peer (#14300) * Add `execution_payload` and `payload_attestation_message` topics (#14304) * Add `execution_payload` and `payload_attestation_message` topics * Set `SourcePubkey` to 48 bytes long * Add randomly populated `PayloadAttestationMessage` object * Add tests for `execution_payload` and `payload_attestation_message` topics * Indexed paylaod attestation test (#14299) * test-added * nil check fix * randomized inputs * hardcoded inputs * suggestions applied * minor-typo fixed * deleted * Process Execution Payload Envelope in Chain Service (#14295) Adds the processing of execution payload envelope Corrects the protos for attestations and slashings in Electra versions Adds generators of full blocks for Electra * Implement OnPayloadAttestationMessage; add setters and required fields * Update ptcVote from byte to primitives; update functions * Update fields in struct * fix lint error: unnecessary conversion * fix lint error: unnecessary conversion * organize code; move ptcVote to node from store * add check to avoid computation if the payload boost is already applied * cleanup * update code to loop over bitfield * fix deepsource errors * use preset value instead of .len() * Payload Attestation Sync package changes (#13989) * Payload Attestation Sync package changes * With verifier * change idx back to uint64 * subscribe to topic * add back error --------- Co-authored-by: terence tsao <terence@prysmaticlabs.com> * change the name of the function; Add comprehensive comments * Add comprehensive unit tests for updateVotes function * fix unused var * fix nits * only updateBoosts onDemand * handle potential equivocation * Add protos for ePBS except state * Add ePBS beacon state proto * ePBS configuration constants * Helper for Payload Attestation Signing (#13901) * Add ePBS stuff to consensus-types: block * Add testing utility methods to return randomly populated ePBS objects * Add ePBS to state (#13926) * Implement get_ptc This implements a helper to get the ptc committee from a state. It uses the cached beacon committees if possible It also implements a helper to compute the largest power of two of a uint64 and a helper to test for nil payload attestation messages * Add EPBS slashing params * Add ePBS to db (#13971) * Add ePBS to db * Fix GetPayloadTimelinessCommittee to return correct PTC size (#14012) * Change gwei math to primitives package for ePBS state * use Keymanager() in validator client * Add PTC assignment support for Duty endpoint (#14032) * Enable validator client to submit payload attestation message (#14064) * Remove inclusion list from epbs (#14188) * Modify `get_ptc` function to follow the Python spec (#14256) * Modify `get_ptc` function to follow the Python spec * Assign PTC members from the beginning of beacon committee array * Add `remove_flag` and its unit test (#14260) * Add `remove_flag` and its unit test * Add a test case trying to remove a flag that is not set * Ensure epbs state getters & setters check versions (#14276) * Ensure EPBS state getters and setters check versions * Rename to LatestExecutionPayloadHeaderEPBS * Add minimal beacon state * Use slot for latest message in forkchoice (#14279) * Add payload attestation helper functions (#14258) * Add `IndexedPayloadAttestation` container * Add `GetPayloadAttestingIndices` and its unit test * Add `GetIndexedPayloadAttestation` and its unit test * Add `is_valid_indexed_payload_attestation` and its unit test * Create a smaller set of validators for faster unit test * Pass context to `GetPayloadTimelinessCommittee` * Iterate `ValidatorsReadOnly` instead of copying all validators * Use BeaconCommittees helper to get the ptc (#14286) * Allow nodes with and without payload in forkchoice (#14288) * Allow nodes with and without payload in forkchoice This PR takes care of adding nodes to forkchoice that may or may not have a corresponding payload. The rationale is as follows - The node structure is kept almost the same as today. - A zero payload hash is considered as if the node was empty (except for the tree root) - When inserting a node we check what the right parent node would be depending on whether the parent had a payload or not. - For pre-epbs forks all nodes are full, no logic changes except a new steps to gather the parent hash that is needed for block insertion. This PR had to change some core consensus types and interfaces. - It removed the ROBlockEPBS interface and added the corresponding ePBS fields to the ReadOnlyBeaconBlockBody - It moved the setters and getters to epbs dedicated files. It also added a checker for `IsParentFull` on forkchoice that simply checks for the parent hash of the parent node. * review * Read only payload attestation message with Verifier (#14222) * Read only payload attestation message with verifier * Payload attestation tests (#14242) * Payload attestation in verification package * Feedback #1 --------- Co-authored-by: Md Amaan <114795592+Redidacove@users.noreply.github.com> * Broadcast signed execution payload header to peer (#14300) * Add `execution_payload` and `payload_attestation_message` topics (#14304) * Add `execution_payload` and `payload_attestation_message` topics * Set `SourcePubkey` to 48 bytes long * Add randomly populated `PayloadAttestationMessage` object * Add tests for `execution_payload` and `payload_attestation_message` topics * Indexed paylaod attestation test (#14299) * test-added * nil check fix * randomized inputs * hardcoded inputs * suggestions applied * minor-typo fixed * deleted * Process Execution Payload Envelope in Chain Service (#14295) Adds the processing of execution payload envelope Corrects the protos for attestations and slashings in Electra versions Adds generators of full blocks for Electra * Payload Attestation Sync package changes (#13989) * Payload Attestation Sync package changes * With verifier * change idx back to uint64 * subscribe to topic * add back error --------- Co-authored-by: terence tsao <terence@prysmaticlabs.com> * Add getter for payload attestation cache (#14328) * Add getter for payload attestation cache * Check against status * Feedback #1 * Initialize payload att message verfier in sync (#14323) * Enable validator client to sign execution header (#14333) * Enable validator client to sign execution header * Update proto/prysm/v1alpha1/validator-client/keymanager.proto --------- Co-authored-by: Potuz <potuz@prysmaticlabs.com> * Process withdrawal (#14297) * process_withdrawal_fn and isParentfull test * suggestions applied * minor change * removed * lint * lint fix * removed Latestheader * test added with nil error * tests passing * IsParentNode Test added * lint * fix test * updated godoc * fix in godoc * comment removed * fixed braces * removed var * removed var * Update beacon-chain/core/blocks/withdrawals.go * Update beacon-chain/core/blocks/withdrawals_test.go * gazelle * test added and removed previous changes in Testprocesswithdrawal * added check for nil state * decrease chromatic complexity --------- Co-authored-by: Potuz <potuz@potuz.net> Co-authored-by: Potuz <potuz@prysmaticlabs.com> * Update tests * undo changes * UpdateVote independent of timing; updatePayloadboosts if the block is early * fix deep source * remove timinng checks; move to onDemand payloadBoosts; update testCases for the changes * update errors and returns; update test cases for the changes * fix deep source errors * reduce cyclomatic complexity * gazelle fix * remove a comment Co-authored-by: Potuz <potuz@potuz.net> * fix duplication in beacon-chain config * fix config tests * fix number of config params --------- Co-authored-by: Potuz <potuz@prysmaticlabs.com> Co-authored-by: terence <terence@prysmaticlabs.com> Co-authored-by: JihoonSong <jihoonsong@users.noreply.github.com> Co-authored-by: Md Amaan <114795592+Redidacove@users.noreply.github.com> Co-authored-by: Potuz <potuz@potuz.net>

* Add getter for payload attestation cache * Check against status * Feedback #1

* Add protos for ePBS except state * Add ePBS beacon state proto * ePBS configuration constants * Helper for Payload Attestation Signing (#13901) * Add ePBS stuff to consensus-types: block * Add testing utility methods to return randomly populated ePBS objects * Add ePBS to state (#13926) * Implement get_ptc This implements a helper to get the ptc committee from a state. It uses the cached beacon committees if possible It also implements a helper to compute the largest power of two of a uint64 and a helper to test for nil payload attestation messages * Add EPBS slashing params * Add ePBS to db (#13971) * Add ePBS to db * Fix GetPayloadTimelinessCommittee to return correct PTC size (#14012) * Change gwei math to primitives package for ePBS state * use Keymanager() in validator client * Add PTC assignment support for Duty endpoint (#14032) * Enable validator client to submit payload attestation message (#14064) * Remove inclusion list from epbs (#14188) * Modify `get_ptc` function to follow the Python spec (#14256) * Modify `get_ptc` function to follow the Python spec * Assign PTC members from the beginning of beacon committee array * Add `remove_flag` and its unit test (#14260) * Add `remove_flag` and its unit test * Add a test case trying to remove a flag that is not set * Ensure epbs state getters & setters check versions (#14276) * Ensure EPBS state getters and setters check versions * Rename to LatestExecutionPayloadHeaderEPBS * Add minimal beacon state * Use slot for latest message in forkchoice (#14279) * Add payload attestation helper functions (#14258) * Add `IndexedPayloadAttestation` container * Add `GetPayloadAttestingIndices` and its unit test * Add `GetIndexedPayloadAttestation` and its unit test * Add `is_valid_indexed_payload_attestation` and its unit test * Create a smaller set of validators for faster unit test * Pass context to `GetPayloadTimelinessCommittee` * Iterate `ValidatorsReadOnly` instead of copying all validators * Use BeaconCommittees helper to get the ptc (#14286) * Allow nodes with and without payload in forkchoice (#14288) * Allow nodes with and without payload in forkchoice This PR takes care of adding nodes to forkchoice that may or may not have a corresponding payload. The rationale is as follows - The node structure is kept almost the same as today. - A zero payload hash is considered as if the node was empty (except for the tree root) - When inserting a node we check what the right parent node would be depending on whether the parent had a payload or not. - For pre-epbs forks all nodes are full, no logic changes except a new steps to gather the parent hash that is needed for block insertion. This PR had to change some core consensus types and interfaces. - It removed the ROBlockEPBS interface and added the corresponding ePBS fields to the ReadOnlyBeaconBlockBody - It moved the setters and getters to epbs dedicated files. It also added a checker for `IsParentFull` on forkchoice that simply checks for the parent hash of the parent node. * review * Read only payload attestation message with Verifier (#14222) * Read only payload attestation message with verifier * Payload attestation tests (#14242) * Payload attestation in verification package * Feedback #1 --------- Co-authored-by: Md Amaan <114795592+Redidacove@users.noreply.github.com> * Broadcast signed execution payload header to peer (#14300) * Add `execution_payload` and `payload_attestation_message` topics (#14304) * Add `execution_payload` and `payload_attestation_message` topics * Set `SourcePubkey` to 48 bytes long * Add randomly populated `PayloadAttestationMessage` object * Add tests for `execution_payload` and `payload_attestation_message` topics * Indexed paylaod attestation test (#14299) * test-added * nil check fix * randomized inputs * hardcoded inputs * suggestions applied * minor-typo fixed * deleted * Process Execution Payload Envelope in Chain Service (#14295) Adds the processing of execution payload envelope Corrects the protos for attestations and slashings in Electra versions Adds generators of full blocks for Electra * Implement OnPayloadAttestationMessage; add setters and required fields * Update ptcVote from byte to primitives; update functions * Update fields in struct * fix lint error: unnecessary conversion * fix lint error: unnecessary conversion * organize code; move ptcVote to node from store * add check to avoid computation if the payload boost is already applied * cleanup * update code to loop over bitfield * fix deepsource errors * use preset value instead of .len() * Payload Attestation Sync package changes (#13989) * Payload Attestation Sync package changes * With verifier * change idx back to uint64 * subscribe to topic * add back error --------- Co-authored-by: terence tsao <terence@prysmaticlabs.com> * change the name of the function; Add comprehensive comments * Add comprehensive unit tests for updateVotes function * fix unused var * fix nits * only updateBoosts onDemand * handle potential equivocation * Add protos for ePBS except state * Add ePBS beacon state proto * ePBS configuration constants * Helper for Payload Attestation Signing (#13901) * Add ePBS stuff to consensus-types: block * Add testing utility methods to return randomly populated ePBS objects * Add ePBS to state (#13926) * Implement get_ptc This implements a helper to get the ptc committee from a state. It uses the cached beacon committees if possible It also implements a helper to compute the largest power of two of a uint64 and a helper to test for nil payload attestation messages * Add EPBS slashing params * Add ePBS to db (#13971) * Add ePBS to db * Fix GetPayloadTimelinessCommittee to return correct PTC size (#14012) * Change gwei math to primitives package for ePBS state * use Keymanager() in validator client * Add PTC assignment support for Duty endpoint (#14032) * Enable validator client to submit payload attestation message (#14064) * Remove inclusion list from epbs (#14188) * Modify `get_ptc` function to follow the Python spec (#14256) * Modify `get_ptc` function to follow the Python spec * Assign PTC members from the beginning of beacon committee array * Add `remove_flag` and its unit test (#14260) * Add `remove_flag` and its unit test * Add a test case trying to remove a flag that is not set * Ensure epbs state getters & setters check versions (#14276) * Ensure EPBS state getters and setters check versions * Rename to LatestExecutionPayloadHeaderEPBS * Add minimal beacon state * Use slot for latest message in forkchoice (#14279) * Add payload attestation helper functions (#14258) * Add `IndexedPayloadAttestation` container * Add `GetPayloadAttestingIndices` and its unit test * Add `GetIndexedPayloadAttestation` and its unit test * Add `is_valid_indexed_payload_attestation` and its unit test * Create a smaller set of validators for faster unit test * Pass context to `GetPayloadTimelinessCommittee` * Iterate `ValidatorsReadOnly` instead of copying all validators * Use BeaconCommittees helper to get the ptc (#14286) * Allow nodes with and without payload in forkchoice (#14288) * Allow nodes with and without payload in forkchoice This PR takes care of adding nodes to forkchoice that may or may not have a corresponding payload. The rationale is as follows - The node structure is kept almost the same as today. - A zero payload hash is considered as if the node was empty (except for the tree root) - When inserting a node we check what the right parent node would be depending on whether the parent had a payload or not. - For pre-epbs forks all nodes are full, no logic changes except a new steps to gather the parent hash that is needed for block insertion. This PR had to change some core consensus types and interfaces. - It removed the ROBlockEPBS interface and added the corresponding ePBS fields to the ReadOnlyBeaconBlockBody - It moved the setters and getters to epbs dedicated files. It also added a checker for `IsParentFull` on forkchoice that simply checks for the parent hash of the parent node. * review * Read only payload attestation message with Verifier (#14222) * Read only payload attestation message with verifier * Payload attestation tests (#14242) * Payload attestation in verification package * Feedback #1 --------- Co-authored-by: Md Amaan <114795592+Redidacove@users.noreply.github.com> * Broadcast signed execution payload header to peer (#14300) * Add `execution_payload` and `payload_attestation_message` topics (#14304) * Add `execution_payload` and `payload_attestation_message` topics * Set `SourcePubkey` to 48 bytes long * Add randomly populated `PayloadAttestationMessage` object * Add tests for `execution_payload` and `payload_attestation_message` topics * Indexed paylaod attestation test (#14299) * test-added * nil check fix * randomized inputs * hardcoded inputs * suggestions applied * minor-typo fixed * deleted * Process Execution Payload Envelope in Chain Service (#14295) Adds the processing of execution payload envelope Corrects the protos for attestations and slashings in Electra versions Adds generators of full blocks for Electra * Payload Attestation Sync package changes (#13989) * Payload Attestation Sync package changes * With verifier * change idx back to uint64 * subscribe to topic * add back error --------- Co-authored-by: terence tsao <terence@prysmaticlabs.com> * Add getter for payload attestation cache (#14328) * Add getter for payload attestation cache * Check against status * Feedback #1 * Initialize payload att message verfier in sync (#14323) * Enable validator client to sign execution header (#14333) * Enable validator client to sign execution header * Update proto/prysm/v1alpha1/validator-client/keymanager.proto --------- Co-authored-by: Potuz <potuz@prysmaticlabs.com> * Process withdrawal (#14297) * process_withdrawal_fn and isParentfull test * suggestions applied * minor change * removed * lint * lint fix * removed Latestheader * test added with nil error * tests passing * IsParentNode Test added * lint * fix test * updated godoc * fix in godoc * comment removed * fixed braces * removed var * removed var * Update beacon-chain/core/blocks/withdrawals.go * Update beacon-chain/core/blocks/withdrawals_test.go * gazelle * test added and removed previous changes in Testprocesswithdrawal * added check for nil state * decrease chromatic complexity --------- Co-authored-by: Potuz <potuz@potuz.net> Co-authored-by: Potuz <potuz@prysmaticlabs.com> * Update tests * undo changes * UpdateVote independent of timing; updatePayloadboosts if the block is early * fix deep source * remove timinng checks; move to onDemand payloadBoosts; update testCases for the changes * update errors and returns; update test cases for the changes * fix deep source errors * reduce cyclomatic complexity * gazelle fix * remove a comment Co-authored-by: Potuz <potuz@potuz.net> * fix duplication in beacon-chain config * fix config tests * fix number of config params --------- Co-authored-by: Potuz <potuz@prysmaticlabs.com> Co-authored-by: terence <terence@prysmaticlabs.com> Co-authored-by: JihoonSong <jihoonsong@users.noreply.github.com> Co-authored-by: Md Amaan <114795592+Redidacove@users.noreply.github.com> Co-authored-by: Potuz <potuz@potuz.net>

* Add getter for payload attestation cache * Check against status * Feedback #1

terencechain requested a review from a team as a code owner August 9, 2024 18:08

terencechain requested review from potuz, rkapka and james-prysm and removed request for a team August 9, 2024 18:08

terencechain force-pushed the payload-attestation-cache-get branch from 6054f21 to 696a74a Compare August 9, 2024 18:09

Add getter for payload attestation cache

08d69f1

terencechain force-pushed the payload-attestation-cache-get branch from 696a74a to 08d69f1 Compare August 9, 2024 18:18

potuz reviewed Aug 9, 2024

View reviewed changes

Check against status

dd4127b

terencechain added the ePBS EIP-7732 label Aug 9, 2024

jihoonsong reviewed Aug 12, 2024

View reviewed changes

Feedback #1

cda6fa3

jihoonsong approved these changes Aug 12, 2024

View reviewed changes

potuz approved these changes Aug 12, 2024

View reviewed changes

potuz merged commit f409686 into epbs Aug 12, 2024
16 checks passed

potuz deleted the payload-attestation-cache-get branch August 12, 2024 20:27

potuz pushed a commit that referenced this pull request Aug 13, 2024

Add getter for payload attestation cache (#14328)

8f13f41

* Add getter for payload attestation cache * Check against status * Feedback #1

potuz pushed a commit that referenced this pull request Aug 14, 2024

Add getter for payload attestation cache (#14328)

374cf59

* Add getter for payload attestation cache * Check against status * Feedback #1

potuz pushed a commit that referenced this pull request Aug 14, 2024

Add getter for payload attestation cache (#14328)

d594939

* Add getter for payload attestation cache * Check against status * Feedback #1

potuz pushed a commit that referenced this pull request Aug 29, 2024

Add getter for payload attestation cache (#14328)

b7a043c

* Add getter for payload attestation cache * Check against status * Feedback #1

potuz pushed a commit that referenced this pull request Sep 13, 2024

Add getter for payload attestation cache (#14328)

e1943b7

* Add getter for payload attestation cache * Check against status * Feedback #1

potuz pushed a commit that referenced this pull request Sep 18, 2024

Add getter for payload attestation cache (#14328)

f54bb58

* Add getter for payload attestation cache * Check against status * Feedback #1

potuz pushed a commit that referenced this pull request Sep 26, 2024

Add getter for payload attestation cache (#14328)

dc538b9

* Add getter for payload attestation cache * Check against status * Feedback #1

potuz pushed a commit that referenced this pull request Oct 7, 2024

Add getter for payload attestation cache (#14328)

f1fff3a

* Add getter for payload attestation cache * Check against status * Feedback #1

potuz pushed a commit that referenced this pull request Oct 14, 2024

Add getter for payload attestation cache (#14328)

9ef713b

* Add getter for payload attestation cache * Check against status * Feedback #1

potuz pushed a commit that referenced this pull request Oct 16, 2024

Add getter for payload attestation cache (#14328)

2435bf7

* Add getter for payload attestation cache * Check against status * Feedback #1

Provide feedback

Saved searches

Use saved searches to filter your results more quickly

Add getter for payload attestation cache #14328

Add getter for payload attestation cache #14328

terencechain commented Aug 9, 2024

potuz Aug 9, 2024

jihoonsong Aug 12, 2024

jihoonsong commented Aug 12, 2024

Add getter for payload attestation cache #14328

Add getter for payload attestation cache #14328

Conversation

terencechain commented Aug 9, 2024

potuz Aug 9, 2024

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

jihoonsong Aug 12, 2024

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

jihoonsong commented Aug 12, 2024