Skip to content
This repository has been archived by the owner on Apr 26, 2024. It is now read-only.

Return the same error message from /login when password is incorrect and when account doesn't exist. #12738

Merged

Conversation

Danieloni1
Copy link
Contributor

@Danieloni1 Danieloni1 commented May 15, 2022

Currently when a user attempts login before registration, we respond with 403 and an empty string message.
In cases where a user was registered and bound to a 3pid already, we return "Invalid Password" as a message.
2 issues arise from this behavior:

  • The major one is user existence leak exposing synapse to an enumeration attack. Having 2 different error messages for unregistered users and registered users who've entered the wrong password essentially leaks the information about that particular user's existence.
  • While another issue is having a non-informative error message in the current approach. As the user wasn't yet registered, it has no password, so essentially no password is valid, making it reasonable to return "Invalid Password" instead of just "".

Signed-off-by: Daniel Aloni daniel@globekeeper.com

@Danieloni1 Danieloni1 requested a review from a team as a code owner May 15, 2022 12:19
Danieloni1 added a commit to globekeeper/synapse that referenced this pull request May 15, 2022
Danieloni1 added a commit to globekeeper/synapse that referenced this pull request May 15, 2022
@Danieloni1 Danieloni1 force-pushed the daniel-aloni/threepid-login-error branch from b1bad4e to f3eedf0 Compare May 15, 2022 12:25
Copy link
Member

@erikjohnston erikjohnston left a comment

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.

This is great, thank you! The changelog just needs moving.

changelog.d/12738.type Outdated Show resolved Hide resolved
@dklimpel
Copy link
Contributor

Is it useful to define a constant to keep the messages synchronised?

@Danieloni1 Danieloni1 force-pushed the daniel-aloni/threepid-login-error branch from f3eedf0 to f5b8a90 Compare May 17, 2022 08:45
@Danieloni1
Copy link
Contributor Author

Is it useful to define a constant to keep the messages synchronised?

@dklimpel
I totally agree!
Maybe I'll have that in my next contribution? 😄

@clokep clokep requested a review from erikjohnston June 1, 2022 11:53
@Danieloni1
Copy link
Contributor Author

Seems like the only failed lint test:
/home/runner/work/_temp/ab7a9a8c-c581-4c82-8009-7efb6bf5ba4a.sh: line 1: scripts-dev/check-newsfragment.sh: No such file or directory
Is not related to my change (which is essentially only modifying a string). Maybe we can promote this?

@erikjohnston
Copy link
Member

Seems like the only failed lint test: /home/runner/work/_temp/ab7a9a8c-c581-4c82-8009-7efb6bf5ba4a.sh: line 1: scripts-dev/check-newsfragment.sh: No such file or directory Is not related to my change (which is essentially only modifying a string). Maybe we can promote this?

You need to merge in the develop branch into this PR. Normally I can do that for you, but for some reason github isn't showing me the Update Branch button...

@richvdh
Copy link
Member

richvdh commented Jun 6, 2022

@erikjohnston please can you make sure this PR gets a better summary before merging? I don't understand it at present.

Copy link
Contributor

@DMRobertson DMRobertson left a comment

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.

As per @richvdh's comment:

changelog.d/12738.misc Outdated Show resolved Hide resolved
@erikjohnston erikjohnston changed the title Upon 403 login attempt by account which doesn't exist return Invalid Password Return the same error message from /login when password is incorrect and when account doesn't exist. Jun 6, 2022
Copy link
Contributor

@DMRobertson DMRobertson left a comment

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.

As Erik says in #12738 (comment), can you merge in the develop branch please?

Edit: it also looks like you'll need to run the linter script.

@Danieloni1 Danieloni1 force-pushed the daniel-aloni/threepid-login-error branch from 0323a9b to a80db50 Compare June 7, 2022 14:22
Copy link
Contributor

@DMRobertson DMRobertson left a comment

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.

Thanks, SGTM

@DMRobertson DMRobertson enabled auto-merge (squash) June 7, 2022 14:37
@DMRobertson DMRobertson merged commit b5a3aec into matrix-org:develop Jun 7, 2022
Danieloni1 added a commit to globekeeper/synapse that referenced this pull request Jun 8, 2022
Danieloni1 added a commit to globekeeper/synapse that referenced this pull request Jun 8, 2022
Fizzadar added a commit to beeper/synapse-legacy-fork that referenced this pull request Aug 23, 2022
Synapse 1.62.0 (2022-07-05)
===========================

No significant changes since 1.62.0rc3.

Authors of spam-checker plugins should consult the [upgrade notes](https://github.com/matrix-org/synapse/blob/release-v1.62/docs/upgrade.md#upgrading-to-v1620) to learn about the enriched signatures for spam checker callbacks, which are supported with this release of Synapse.

Synapse 1.62.0rc3 (2022-07-04)
==============================

Bugfixes
--------

- Update the version of the [ldap3 plugin](https://github.com/matrix-org/matrix-synapse-ldap3/) included in the `matrixdotorg/synapse` DockerHub images and the Debian packages hosted on `packages.matrix.org` to 0.2.1. This fixes [a bug](matrix-org/matrix-synapse-ldap3#163) with usernames containing uppercase characters. ([\matrix-org#13156](matrix-org#13156))
- Fix a bug introduced in Synapse 1.62.0rc1 affecting unread counts for users on small servers. ([\matrix-org#13168](matrix-org#13168))

Synapse 1.62.0rc2 (2022-07-01)
==============================

Bugfixes
--------

- Fix unread counts for users on large servers. Introduced in v1.62.0rc1. ([\matrix-org#13140](matrix-org#13140))
- Fix DB performance when deleting old push notifications. Introduced in v1.62.0rc1. ([\matrix-org#13141](matrix-org#13141))

Synapse 1.62.0rc1 (2022-06-28)
==============================

Features
--------

- Port the spam-checker API callbacks to a new, richer API. This is part of an ongoing change to let spam-checker modules inform users of the reason their event or operation is rejected. ([\matrix-org#12857](matrix-org#12857), [\matrix-org#13047](matrix-org#13047))
- Allow server admins to customise the response of the `/.well-known/matrix/client` endpoint. ([\matrix-org#13035](matrix-org#13035))
- Add metrics measuring the CPU and DB time spent in state resolution. ([\matrix-org#13036](matrix-org#13036))
- Speed up fetching of device list changes in `/sync` and `/keys/changes`. ([\matrix-org#13045](matrix-org#13045), [\matrix-org#13098](matrix-org#13098))
- Improve URL previews for sites which only provide Twitter Card metadata, e.g. LWN.net. ([\matrix-org#13056](matrix-org#13056))

Bugfixes
--------

- Update [MSC3786](matrix-org/matrix-spec-proposals#3786) implementation to check `state_key`. ([\matrix-org#12939](matrix-org#12939))
- Fix a bug introduced in Synapse 1.58 where Synapse would not report full version information when installed from a git checkout. This is a best-effort affair and not guaranteed to be stable. ([\matrix-org#12973](matrix-org#12973))
- Fix a bug introduced in Synapse 1.60 where Synapse would fail to start if the `sqlite3` module was not available. ([\matrix-org#12979](matrix-org#12979))
- Fix a bug where non-standard information was required when requesting the `/hierarchy` API over federation. Introduced
  in Synapse v1.41.0. ([\matrix-org#12991](matrix-org#12991))
- Fix a long-standing bug which meant that rate limiting was not restrictive enough in some cases. ([\matrix-org#13018](matrix-org#13018))
- Fix a bug introduced in Synapse 1.58 where profile requests for a malformed user ID would ccause an internal error. Synapse now returns 400 Bad Request in this situation. ([\matrix-org#13041](matrix-org#13041))
- Fix some inconsistencies in the event authentication code. ([\matrix-org#13087](matrix-org#13087), [\matrix-org#13088](matrix-org#13088))
- Fix a long-standing bug where room directory requests would cause an internal server error if given a malformed room alias. ([\matrix-org#13106](matrix-org#13106))

Improved Documentation
----------------------

- Add documentation for how to configure Synapse with Workers using Docker Compose. Includes example worker config and docker-compose.yaml. Contributed by @Thumbscrew. ([\matrix-org#12737](matrix-org#12737))
- Ensure the [Poetry cheat sheet](https://matrix-org.github.io/synapse/develop/development/dependencies.html) is available in the online documentation. ([\matrix-org#13022](matrix-org#13022))
- Mention removed community/group worker endpoints in upgrade.md. Contributed by @olmari. ([\matrix-org#13023](matrix-org#13023))
- Add instructions for running Complement with `gotestfmt`-formatted output locally. ([\matrix-org#13073](matrix-org#13073))
- Update OpenTracing docs to reference the configuration manual rather than the configuration file. ([\matrix-org#13076](matrix-org#13076))
- Update information on downstream Debian packages. ([\matrix-org#13095](matrix-org#13095))
- Remove documentation for the Delete Group Admin API which no longer exists. ([\matrix-org#13112](matrix-org#13112))

Deprecations and Removals
-------------------------

- Remove the unspecced `DELETE /directory/list/room/{roomId}` endpoint, which hid rooms from the [public room directory](https://spec.matrix.org/v1.3/client-server-api/#listing-rooms). Instead, `PUT` to the same URL with a visibility of `"private"`. ([\matrix-org#13123](matrix-org#13123))

Internal Changes
----------------

- Add tests for cancellation of `GET /rooms/$room_id/members` and `GET /rooms/$room_id/state` requests. ([\matrix-org#12674](matrix-org#12674))
- Report login failures due to unknown third party identifiers in the same way as failures due to invalid passwords. This prevents an attacker from using the error response to determine if the identifier exists. Contributed by Daniel Aloni. ([\matrix-org#12738](matrix-org#12738))
- Merge the Complement testing Docker images into a single, multi-purpose image. ([\matrix-org#12881](matrix-org#12881), [\matrix-org#13075](matrix-org#13075))
- Simplify the database schema for `event_edges`. ([\matrix-org#12893](matrix-org#12893))
- Clean up the test code for client disconnection. ([\matrix-org#12929](matrix-org#12929))
- Remove code generating comments in configuration. ([\matrix-org#12941](matrix-org#12941))
- Add `Cross-Origin-Resource-Policy: cross-origin` header to content repository's thumbnail and download endpoints. ([\matrix-org#12944](matrix-org#12944))
- Replace noop background updates with `DELETE` delta. ([\matrix-org#12954](matrix-org#12954), [\matrix-org#13050](matrix-org#13050))
- Use lower isolation level when inserting read receipts to avoid serialization errors. Contributed by Nick @ Beeper. ([\matrix-org#12957](matrix-org#12957))
- Reduce the amount of state we pull from the DB. ([\matrix-org#12963](matrix-org#12963))
- Enable testing against PostgreSQL databases in Complement CI. ([\matrix-org#12965](matrix-org#12965), [\matrix-org#13034](matrix-org#13034))
- Fix an inaccurate comment. ([\matrix-org#12969](matrix-org#12969))
- Remove the `delete_device` method and always call `delete_devices`. ([\matrix-org#12970](matrix-org#12970))
- Use a GitHub form for issues rather than a hard-to-read, easy-to-ignore template. ([\matrix-org#12982](matrix-org#12982))
- Move [MSC3715](matrix-org/matrix-spec-proposals#3715) behind an experimental config flag. ([\matrix-org#12984](matrix-org#12984))
- Add type hints to tests. ([\matrix-org#12985](matrix-org#12985), [\matrix-org#13099](matrix-org#13099))
- Refactor macaroon tokens generation and move the unsubscribe link in notification emails to `/_synapse/client/unsubscribe`. ([\matrix-org#12986](matrix-org#12986))
- Fix documentation for running complement tests. ([\matrix-org#12990](matrix-org#12990))
- Faster joins: add issue links to the TODO comments in the code. ([\matrix-org#13004](matrix-org#13004))
- Reduce DB usage of `/sync` when a large number of unread messages have recently been sent in a room. ([\matrix-org#13005](matrix-org#13005), [\matrix-org#13096](matrix-org#13096), [\matrix-org#13118](matrix-org#13118))
- Replaced usage of PyJWT with methods from Authlib in `org.matrix.login.jwt`. Contributed by Hannes Lerchl. ([\matrix-org#13011](matrix-org#13011))
- Modernize the `contrib/graph/` scripts. ([\matrix-org#13013](matrix-org#13013))
- Remove redundant `room_version` parameters from event auth functions. ([\matrix-org#13017](matrix-org#13017))
- Decouple `synapse.api.auth_blocking.AuthBlocking` from `synapse.api.auth.Auth`. ([\matrix-org#13021](matrix-org#13021))
- Add type annotations to `synapse.storage.databases.main.devices`. ([\matrix-org#13025](matrix-org#13025))
- Set default `sync_response_cache_duration` to two minutes. ([\matrix-org#13042](matrix-org#13042))
- Rename CI test runs. ([\matrix-org#13046](matrix-org#13046))
- Increase timeout of complement CI test runs. ([\matrix-org#13048](matrix-org#13048))
- Refactor entry points so that they all have a `main` function. ([\matrix-org#13052](matrix-org#13052))
- Refactor the Dockerfile-workers configuration script to use Jinja2 templates in Synapse workers' Supervisord blocks. ([\matrix-org#13054](matrix-org#13054))
- Add headers to individual options in config documentation to allow for linking. ([\matrix-org#13055](matrix-org#13055))
- Make Complement CI logs easier to read. ([\matrix-org#13057](matrix-org#13057), [\matrix-org#13058](matrix-org#13058), [\matrix-org#13069](matrix-org#13069))
- Don't instantiate modules with keyword arguments. ([\matrix-org#13060](matrix-org#13060))
- Fix type checking errors against Twisted trunk. ([\matrix-org#13061](matrix-org#13061))
- Allow MSC3030 `timestamp_to_event` calls from anyone on world-readable rooms. ([\matrix-org#13062](matrix-org#13062))
- Add a CI job to check that schema deltas are in the correct folder. ([\matrix-org#13063](matrix-org#13063))
- Avoid rechecking event auth rules which are independent of room state. ([\matrix-org#13065](matrix-org#13065))
- Reduce the duplication of code that invokes the rate limiter. ([\matrix-org#13070](matrix-org#13070))
- Add a Subject Alternative Name to the certificate generated for Complement tests. ([\matrix-org#13071](matrix-org#13071))
- Add more tests for room upgrades. ([\matrix-org#13074](matrix-org#13074))
- Pin dependencies maintained by matrix.org to [semantic version](https://semver.org/) bounds. ([\matrix-org#13082](matrix-org#13082))
- Correctly report prometheus DB stats for `get_earliest_token_for_stats`. ([\matrix-org#13085](matrix-org#13085))
- Fix a long-standing bug where a finished logging context would be re-started when Synapse failed to persist an event from federation. ([\matrix-org#13089](matrix-org#13089))
- Simplify the alias deletion logic as an application service. ([\matrix-org#13093](matrix-org#13093))
- Add type annotations to `tests.test_server`. ([\matrix-org#13124](matrix-org#13124))
Sign up for free to subscribe to this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in.
Labels
None yet
Projects
None yet
Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

5 participants