Question regarding the correct listID values #interproc

[konstantinosraptis91]

Hello ESPD team,

It seems that some of the examples (snippets) that are included in the technical handbook have different listID attribute values for certain elements compared to the respective Schematron rules. For instance, according to the technical handbook, the correct @listID value for cbc:PropertyGroupType is "property-group-type"

But the relevant Schematron rule demands the @listID value for this element to be equal to "PropertyGroupType". Can you clarify please what are the correct listID values for those elements?

[konstantinosraptis91]

Following the discussion we had in today's OUC (OUC 23-02-2023) considering this issue, I would like to ask because I am unsure if I got it right if this issue will be addressed within the v3.2.0 or later with the v4.0.0 release.

[delgajc]

Good afternoon,

this issue will be addressed with the v4.0.0 release since the scope for v3.2.0 was already closed some weeks ago and this release is about to be published shortly (pending to fix some technical issues).

We are analyzing these inconsistencies in the codelist elements and will provide more information here after the conclusion of the analysis.

Kind Regards,
The ESPD Team.

[konstantinosraptis91]

Hello @delgajc

Thank you for your answer. Can you please provide us with a list containing the exact listID values per codelist expected in version 3.1.0 and 3.2.0 to avoid further misconceptions? It would also be nice if you could update the technical handbook because, as it is right now, it is not clear what are the correct values.

[delgajc]

Dear Konstantinos,

please find below a table with the right listID values per codelist expected in version 3.1.0 and 3.2.0. We will fix the errors in the technical handbook and in the schematron files for 3.2.0, but bear in mind that currently the codelists maintained by ESPD Team are not validating the listID (this attribute is not included in the genericode files). This validation will be included in a future release.

<style> </style>

ShortName	ListID	Maintainer
AccessRight	access-right	EU Vocabularies
BooleanGUIControlType	boolean-gui-control-type	ESPD Team
Country	country	EU Vocabularies
Criterion	criterion	EU Vocabularies
CriterionElementType	criterion-element-type	ESPD Team
Currency	currency	EU Vocabularies
DocRefContentType	docrefcontent-type	EU Vocabularies
EconomicOperatorSize	economic-operator-size	EU Vocabularies
EOIDType	eoid-type	ESPD Team
EoRoleType	eo-role-type	EU Vocabularies
FinancialRatioType	financial-ratio-type	ESPD Team
Language	language	EU Vocabularies
Occupation	occupation	ESPD Team
ProfileExecutionID	profile-execution-id	ESPD Team
PropertyGroupType	property-group-type	ESPD Team
ResponseDataType	response-data-type	ESPD Team

Kind Regards,
The ESPD Team.

[konstantinosraptis91]

Thank you! @delgajc

[Nikanoras]

What about ProcedureType?

[delgajc]

Dear @konstantinosraptis91

there were some mistakes in the table I previously sent. Please find below the correct listID values for all the codelists:

We are working to fix all the discrepancies in the documentation and ESPD artifacts to be included in next release 3.2.0.

Dear @Nikanoras, ProcedureType is an obsolete codelist no longer maintained in ESPD in versions 3.x.x.

Kind regards,
The ESPD Team.

<style> </style>

ShortName	ListID	Maintainer
AccessRight	http://publications.europa.eu/resource/authority/access-right	EU Vocabularies
BooleanGUIControlType	boolean-gui-control-type	ESPD Team
Country	http://publications.europa.eu/resource/authority/country	EU Vocabularies
Criterion	http://publications.europa.eu/resource/authority/criterion	EU Vocabularies
CriterionElementType	criterion-element-type	ESPD Team
Currency	http://publications.europa.eu/resource/authority/currency	EU Vocabularies
DocRefContentType	http://publications.europa.eu/resource/authority/docrefcontent-type	EU Vocabularies
EconomicOperatorSize	http://publications.europa.eu/resource/authority/economic-operator-size	EU Vocabularies
EOIDType	eoid-type	ESPD Team
EoRoleType	http://publications.europa.eu/resource/authority/eo-role-type	EU Vocabularies
FinancialRatioType	financial-ratio-type	ESPD Team
Language	http://publications.europa.eu/resource/authority/language	EU Vocabularies
Occupation	http://publications.europa.eu/resource/authority/occupation	EU Vocabularies
ProfileExecutionID	profile-execution-id	ESPD Team
PropertyGroupType	property-group-type	ESPD Team
ResponseDataType	response-data-type	ESPD Team

[pascalinelaur]

Hello @Nikanoras ,

Related the codelist "ProcedureType", the proper name is actually "ProcurementProcedureType" from the EU Vocabularies.
However, this codelist is not maintain in the ESPD project because the data can be retrieved from the eForms and hence there is no use-context for the ESPD .

For the next release, you will find the element "ProcedureCode" with the attribute "listID" assigned to a Dummy value. You can already check this in the master branch, folder xml-examples.

Kind regards,
The ESPD Team.

[pascalinelaur]

Hello,

The ESPD version 3.2.0 has been released with a broader solution for this github issue. We reviewed all the codelists listID values in XSL file, generic code files, XSLT files, XML files and Schematron files as well. We also updated the listID values in the online documentation.

With all that being said, this issue is resolved and closed.

Kind regards,
The ESPD Team.