Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

fix(contracts-communication): deduplicate versioning libraries #2402

Conversation

ChiTimesChi
Copy link
Collaborator

@ChiTimesChi ChiTimesChi commented Mar 29, 2024

Description
Deduplicates versioning functions introduced in:

Summary by CodeRabbit

  • New Features
    • Enhanced transaction and batch processing with the introduction of VersionedPayloadLib for handling versioned payloads.
  • Refactor
    • Simplified encoding and decoding processes across various contracts and tests by utilizing new library functionalities.
    • Improved code clarity and efficiency in transaction execution and batch verification methods.
  • Tests
    • Updated and added tests to cover the new encoding and decoding functionalities and to ensure compatibility with versioned payloads.

Copy link
Contributor

coderabbitai bot commented Mar 29, 2024

Walkthrough

This comprehensive update introduces the VersionedPayloadLib across various smart contracts and testing harnesses within the contracts-communication package. The changes streamline the encoding and decoding processes for transactions and batches, ensuring compatibility with versioned payloads. This enhancement simplifies interactions and improves the efficiency and readability of the code, reflecting a significant evolution in handling interchain communications and database operations.

Changes

Files Summary
.../contracts/InterchainClientV1.sol, .../contracts/modules/InterchainModule.sol, .../test/InterchainClientV1.Base.t.sol, .../test/InterchainClientV1.Dst.t.sol, .../test/InterchainClientV1.GenericViews.t.sol, .../test/integration/ICIntegration.t.sol, .../test/integration/ICSetup.t.sol Introduced VersionedPayloadLib for enhanced encoding/decoding of transactions.
.../contracts/InterchainDB.sol Modified to use VersionedPayloadLib for versioned payload handling in database operations.
.../contracts/libs/InterchainBatch.sol, .../test/libs/InterchainBatchLib.t.sol Refactored encoding/decoding methods for InterchainBatch objects.
.../contracts/libs/InterchainTransaction.sol, .../test/libs/InterchainTransaction.t.sol Simplified transaction encoding/decoding to use new methods.
.../test/InterchainDB.Dst.t.sol, .../test/InterchainDB.Src.t.sol, .../test/harnesses/InterchainBatchLibHarness.sol, .../test/harnesses/InterchainTransactionLibHarness.sol, .../test/modules/SynapseModule.Destination.t.sol, .../test/modules/SynapseModule.Source.t.sol Updated to incorporate VersionedPayloadLib and harnesses for testing versioned payloads and batches.

🐇✨
In the land of code and light,
A rabbit hopped, its future bright.
With every leap, the code did change,
Streams of data, now rearranged.
Through versioned payloads, clear and keen,
A more efficient world was seen.
🌟📜🚀

Thank you for using CodeRabbit. We offer it for free to the OSS community and would appreciate your support in helping us grow. If you find it useful, would you consider giving us a shout-out on your favorite social media?

Share

Tips

Chat

There are 3 ways to chat with CodeRabbit:

  • Review comments: Directly reply to a review comment made by CodeRabbit. Example:
    • I pushed a fix in commit <commit_id>.
    • Generate unit testing code for this file.
    • Open a follow-up GitHub issue for this discussion.
  • Files and specific lines of code (under the "Files changed" tab): Tag @coderabbitai in a new review comment at the desired location with your query. Examples:
    • @coderabbitai generate unit testing code for this file.
    • @coderabbitai modularize this function.
  • PR comments: Tag @coderabbitai in a new PR comment to ask questions about the PR branch. For the best results, please provide a very specific query, as very limited context is provided in this mode. Examples:
    • @coderabbitai generate interesting stats about this repository and render them as a table.
    • @coderabbitai show all the console.log statements in this repository.
    • @coderabbitai read src/utils.ts and generate unit testing code.
    • @coderabbitai read the files in the src/scheduler package and generate a class diagram using mermaid and a README in the markdown format.

Note: Be mindful of the bot's finite context window. It's strongly recommended to break down tasks such as reading entire modules into smaller chunks. For a focused discussion, use review comments to chat about specific files and their changes, instead of using the PR comments.

CodeRabbit Commands (invoked as PR comments)

  • @coderabbitai pause to pause the reviews on a PR.
  • @coderabbitai resume to resume the paused reviews.
  • @coderabbitai review to trigger a review. This is useful when automatic reviews are disabled for the repository.
  • @coderabbitai resolve resolve all the CodeRabbit review comments.
  • @coderabbitai help to get help.

Additionally, you can add @coderabbitai ignore anywhere in the PR description to prevent this PR from being reviewed.

CodeRabbit Configration File (.coderabbit.yaml)

  • You can programmatically configure CodeRabbit by adding a .coderabbit.yaml file to the root of your repository.
  • The JSON schema for the configuration file is available here.
  • If your editor has YAML language server enabled, you can add the path at the top of this file to enable auto-completion and validation: # yaml-language-server: $schema=https://coderabbit.ai/integrations/coderabbit-overrides.v2.json

CodeRabbit Discord Community

Join our Discord Community to get help, request features, and share feedback.

Copy link

codecov bot commented Mar 29, 2024

Codecov Report

All modified and coverable lines are covered by tests ✅

Project coverage is 46.91493%. Comparing base (5525834) to head (523f1e3).

Additional details and impacted files
@@                             Coverage Diff                              @@
##           feat/interchain-versioning-library       #2402         +/-   ##
============================================================================
- Coverage                            46.91836%   46.91493%   -0.00344%     
============================================================================
  Files                                     383         383                 
  Lines                                   29189       29189                 
  Branches                                   83          83                 
============================================================================
- Hits                                    13695       13694          -1     
  Misses                                  14036       14036                 
- Partials                                 1458        1459          +1     
Flag Coverage Δ
packages 90.52734% <ø> (-0.09767%) ⬇️

Flags with carried forward coverage won't be shown. Click here to find out more.

☔ View full report in Codecov by Sentry.
📢 Have feedback on the report? Share it here.

Copy link

Deploying sanguine-fe with  Cloudflare Pages  Cloudflare Pages

Latest commit: 523f1e3
Status: ✅  Deploy successful!
Preview URL: https://87afd63c.sanguine-fe.pages.dev
Branch Preview URL: https://feat-interchain-versioning-d.sanguine-fe.pages.dev

View logs

Copy link
Contributor

@coderabbitai coderabbitai bot left a comment

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.

Actionable comments posted: 0

Review Status

Configuration used: .coderabbit.yaml

Commits Files that changed from the base of the PR and between 5525834 and 523f1e3.
Files selected for processing (18)
  • packages/contracts-communication/contracts/InterchainClientV1.sol (5 hunks)
  • packages/contracts-communication/contracts/InterchainDB.sol (3 hunks)
  • packages/contracts-communication/contracts/libs/InterchainBatch.sol (1 hunks)
  • packages/contracts-communication/contracts/libs/InterchainTransaction.sol (1 hunks)
  • packages/contracts-communication/contracts/modules/InterchainModule.sol (3 hunks)
  • packages/contracts-communication/test/InterchainClientV1.Base.t.sol (4 hunks)
  • packages/contracts-communication/test/InterchainClientV1.Dst.t.sol (11 hunks)
  • packages/contracts-communication/test/InterchainClientV1.GenericViews.t.sol (2 hunks)
  • packages/contracts-communication/test/InterchainDB.Dst.t.sol (6 hunks)
  • packages/contracts-communication/test/InterchainDB.Src.t.sol (4 hunks)
  • packages/contracts-communication/test/harnesses/InterchainBatchLibHarness.sol (1 hunks)
  • packages/contracts-communication/test/harnesses/InterchainTransactionLibHarness.sol (1 hunks)
  • packages/contracts-communication/test/integration/ICIntegration.t.sol (1 hunks)
  • packages/contracts-communication/test/integration/ICSetup.t.sol (3 hunks)
  • packages/contracts-communication/test/libs/InterchainBatchLib.t.sol (1 hunks)
  • packages/contracts-communication/test/libs/InterchainTransaction.t.sol (3 hunks)
  • packages/contracts-communication/test/modules/SynapseModule.Destination.t.sol (9 hunks)
  • packages/contracts-communication/test/modules/SynapseModule.Source.t.sol (5 hunks)
Additional Context Used
Additional comments not posted (77)
packages/contracts-communication/test/harnesses/InterchainBatchLibHarness.sol (3)

11-12: The encodeBatch function correctly exposes the InterchainBatchLib.encodeBatch functionality for testing. It's good practice to ensure that the library's encoding logic is thoroughly tested, especially since encoding and decoding are critical for data integrity across contracts.


15-16: The decodeBatch function properly exposes the InterchainBatchLib.decodeBatch functionality. This is essential for validating that the encoded data can be accurately decoded back into its original structure. It's important to include comprehensive tests for various edge cases to ensure robustness.


19-20: The decodeBatchFromMemory function is correctly implemented to test decoding of batches from memory using InterchainBatchLib.decodeBatchFromMemory. This adds an additional layer of testing to ensure that decoding works as expected in different contexts (calldata vs. memory). Including tests that compare the results of decodeBatch and decodeBatchFromMemory could be beneficial for ensuring consistency.

packages/contracts-communication/test/harnesses/InterchainTransactionLibHarness.sol (2)

25-26: The encodeTransaction function correctly exposes the InterchainTransactionLib.encodeTransaction functionality for testing. This is crucial for ensuring that transactions are encoded correctly before being sent across chains. It's recommended to include tests that verify the encoded data against expected values to ensure accuracy.


29-30: The decodeTransaction function properly exposes the InterchainTransactionLib.decodeTransaction functionality. Testing the decoding process is essential for ensuring that transactions received from other chains are interpreted correctly. It would be beneficial to test decoding of transactions with various option and message lengths to cover more scenarios.

packages/contracts-communication/contracts/libs/InterchainTransaction.sol (2)

56-57: The encodeTransaction function has been simplified to use abi.encode, which is a straightforward and efficient way to encode structured data in Solidity. This change simplifies the encoding process and reduces the potential for errors. Ensure comprehensive testing is performed to validate the encoded data, especially for transactions with complex or nested structures.


60-61: The decodeTransaction function has been updated to use abi.decode, which matches the simplicity and efficiency of the encoding process. This ensures symmetry between encoding and decoding, which is crucial for data integrity. Testing should include various transaction payloads to ensure that decoding is accurate across all expected input types.

packages/contracts-communication/contracts/libs/InterchainBatch.sol (3)

39-41: The encodeBatch function has been updated to use abi.encode, which is a clean and efficient approach for encoding structured data. This change aligns with best practices for data encoding in Solidity. It's important to ensure that the encoding process is thoroughly tested, particularly for batches with varying sizes and contents.


44-46: The decodeBatch function now uses abi.decode for decoding batch data from calldata. This simplification enhances readability and maintainability of the code. Comprehensive testing should be conducted to verify that batches are decoded correctly, especially when handling complex or large batches.


49-51: The decodeBatchFromMemory function is correctly implemented to decode batch data from memory using abi.decode. This addition ensures that the library can handle batch data in different contexts (calldata vs. memory). Testing for consistency between decodeBatch and decodeBatchFromMemory results is recommended to ensure reliability.

packages/contracts-communication/test/libs/InterchainBatchLib.t.sol (2)

51-54: The test_encodeBatch_roundTrip function correctly tests the round-trip encoding and decoding of InterchainBatch objects using encodeBatch and decodeBatch. This is essential for ensuring data integrity. It's recommended to include various batch sizes and contents in the tests to cover more edge cases.


57-60: The test_encodeBatchFromMemory_roundTrip function tests the round-trip encoding and decoding of InterchainBatch objects using encodeBatch and decodeBatchFromMemory. This adds valuable coverage for different contexts (calldata vs. memory). Expanding the test cases to include batches with complex structures would further ensure the robustness of the encoding and decoding logic.

packages/contracts-communication/test/InterchainClientV1.GenericViews.t.sol (1)

53-54: The test_encodeTransaction function has been updated to use VersionedPayloadLibHarness for extracting the version and payload, which is a good practice for ensuring that the versioning logic is correctly applied. It's important to test with various transaction versions to ensure compatibility and correct decoding across version changes.

packages/contracts-communication/test/libs/InterchainTransaction.t.sol (2)

47-49: The test_encodeTransaction_roundTrip function correctly tests the round-trip encoding and decoding of InterchainTransaction objects. This is crucial for ensuring the integrity of transactions across chains. Including a variety of transaction types and sizes in the tests would enhance coverage and robustness.


62-62: The test_payloadSize function has been updated to include the VersionedPayloadLibHarness in the expected size calculation, which is important for ensuring that the payload size calculation accounts for versioning overhead. Testing with various option and message lengths is recommended to validate the accuracy of the payload size calculation across different scenarios.

packages/contracts-communication/contracts/modules/InterchainModule.sol (2)

29-29: The use of versionedBatch.getPayload() in requestBatchVerification for decoding batches is a good practice, as it ensures that the versioning logic is applied correctly. It's important to test this functionality with batches of different versions to ensure backward compatibility and correct handling of versioned data.


57-57: The use of versionedBatch.getPayloadFromMemory() in _verifyBatch for decoding batches from memory aligns with the changes in requestBatchVerification and ensures consistency in handling versioned data. Testing with various batch sizes and structures is recommended to ensure the robustness of the decoding process.

packages/contracts-communication/test/integration/ICSetup.t.sol (3)

15-16: The addition of InterchainBatchLibHarness and VersionedPayloadLibHarness imports is appropriate for testing purposes, ensuring that the contract can interact with these libraries in a controlled environment.


39-40: The declaration of InterchainBatchLibHarness and VersionedPayloadLibHarness as public variables is correctly done. This allows other contracts or tests to interact with these harness instances, facilitating comprehensive testing scenarios.


64-74: The deployLibraryHarnesses function is well-implemented. It correctly initializes the batchLibHarness and payloadLibHarness by deploying new instances of their respective harness contracts. This setup is crucial for testing the integration with these libraries in a controlled manner.

packages/contracts-communication/test/InterchainClientV1.Base.t.sol (4)

12-13: The addition of InterchainTransactionLibHarness and VersionedPayloadLibHarness imports is correctly done to facilitate testing with these libraries in a controlled environment. This ensures that the contract can interact with these libraries for testing purposes.


31-32: The declaration of InterchainTransactionLibHarness and VersionedPayloadLibHarness as public variables is appropriate. This allows other contracts or tests to interact with these harness instances, which is beneficial for creating comprehensive testing scenarios.


55-56: The initialization of txLibHarness and payloadLibHarness in the constructor is correctly implemented. Deploying new instances of their respective harness contracts is crucial for testing the integration with these libraries in a controlled manner.


239-240: The modification of the getEncodedTx function to use payloadLibHarness for encoding the versioned payload is correctly implemented. This change ensures that the function can leverage the testing harness for VersionedPayloadLib, facilitating more controlled and flexible testing scenarios.

packages/contracts-communication/contracts/InterchainDB.sol (3)

10-10: The import of VersionedPayloadLib is correctly added to enable the handling of versioned payloads within the InterchainDB contract. This library is essential for encoding and decoding versioned data, aligning with the contract's requirements for version compatibility.


71-75: The modification in the verifyRemoteBatch function to use VersionedPayloadLib for decoding the versioned batch is correctly implemented. This change ensures that the function can handle versioned payloads appropriately, checking the version compatibility before proceeding with the batch verification.


224-227: The changes in the requestBatchVerification function to use VersionedPayloadLib for encoding the versioned batch are correctly implemented. This ensures that the function can create versioned payloads in a standardized manner, facilitating interoperability and version compatibility in batch verification requests.

packages/contracts-communication/test/modules/SynapseModule.Source.t.sol (4)

10-11: The addition of InterchainBatchLibHarness and VersionedPayloadLibHarness imports is correctly done to facilitate testing with these libraries in a controlled environment. This ensures that the contract can interact with these libraries for testing purposes.


19-20: The declaration of InterchainBatchLibHarness and VersionedPayloadLibHarness as public variables is appropriate. This allows other contracts or tests to interact with these harness instances, which is beneficial for creating comprehensive testing scenarios.


47-48: The initialization of batchLibHarness and payloadLibHarness in the constructor is correctly implemented. Deploying new instances of their respective harness contracts is crucial for testing the integration with these libraries in a controlled manner.


64-66: The addition of the getVersionedBatch function to handle encoding with batchLibHarness and payloadLibHarness is correctly implemented. This change ensures that the function can leverage the testing harness for InterchainBatchLib and VersionedPayloadLib, facilitating more controlled and flexible testing scenarios.

packages/contracts-communication/test/integration/ICIntegration.t.sol (2)

239-239: Changing the visibility of the getEthSignedBatchHash function from pure to view is appropriate given the function now indirectly interacts with state through the getModuleBatch function. This adjustment aligns with Solidity's visibility and mutability rules.


244-246: The update to the getModuleBatch function to use payloadLibHarness and batchLibHarness for encoding the versioned payload and batch is correctly implemented. This change ensures that the function can leverage the testing harness for VersionedPayloadLib and InterchainBatchLib, facilitating more controlled and flexible testing scenarios.

packages/contracts-communication/test/modules/SynapseModule.Destination.t.sol (9)

11-12: The introduction of InterchainBatchLibHarness and VersionedPayloadLibHarness harnesses is a good practice for isolating and testing the functionality of these libraries in a controlled environment. This approach facilitates more focused and effective testing of the versioning logic.


22-23: The instantiation of InterchainBatchLibHarness and VersionedPayloadLibHarness as public variables allows for easy access and manipulation in test cases. This setup is appropriate for testing purposes, ensuring that the harnesses can be utilized across different test scenarios within this file.


39-39: The declaration of mockVersionedBatch as a bytes array without initialization is acceptable in this context, as it is later assigned a value in the setUp function using getVersionedBatch. This lazy initialization pattern is suitable for test setups where certain values depend on the execution of initialization logic.


59-61: Instantiating the harnesses within the setUp function is a standard practice in testing. It ensures that each test starts with a fresh instance of the necessary components, thereby avoiding unintended side effects from previous tests. This setup contributes to the reliability and independence of the tests.


60-60: The assignment of mockVersionedBatch using getVersionedBatch(mockBatch) within the setUp function is a critical step for preparing the test environment. It ensures that a versioned batch is available for tests that require it, encapsulating the versioning logic in a reusable function. This approach enhances the modularity and maintainability of the test setup.


124-126: The getVersionedBatch function encapsulates the logic for encoding a InterchainBatch into a versioned payload using the VersionedPayloadLibHarness. This function is a key component of the test setup, enabling the simulation of versioned batch processing. The use of a harness for encoding ensures that the versioning logic can be tested in isolation, which is beneficial for identifying and addressing issues specific to version encoding.


177-177: The test case test_verifyRemoteBatch_zeroSignatures_revertNotEnoughSignatures correctly simulates a scenario where a versioned batch is verified with zero signatures, expecting a revert due to not meeting the minimum signature requirement. This test is essential for ensuring the robustness of the batch verification logic against invalid inputs.


214-218: The test cases for verifying remote batches with various signature scenarios (valid, invalid, sorted, unsorted, duplicates) are comprehensive and cover a wide range of possible inputs. These tests are crucial for ensuring the integrity and security of the batch verification process, validating that only correctly signed and ordered signatures allow a batch to be verified successfully.


316-319: The test case test_verifyRemoteBatch_revertSameChainId effectively checks the logic for preventing the verification of a batch originating from the same chain as the destination. This test ensures that the system adheres to the intended behavior of only allowing interchain transactions between distinct chains, which is a fundamental aspect of the interchain communication protocol.

packages/contracts-communication/contracts/InterchainClientV1.sol (5)

19-19: The addition of VersionedPayloadLib import is a crucial step for enabling versioned payload handling within the InterchainClientV1 contract. This library provides the necessary functionality for encoding and decoding versioned data, which is integral to the contract's operation in handling versioned interchain transactions.


30-30: Utilizing VersionedPayloadLib with a using statement for bytes simplifies the syntax for calling library functions on byte arrays. This approach enhances code readability and maintainability by allowing direct invocation of versioning functions on byte array variables, which are commonly used to represent encoded data.


214-218: The refactored encodeTransaction function now leverages VersionedPayloadLib to encode interchain transactions with a version prefix. This modification is essential for ensuring compatibility across different versions of interchain transactions, facilitating future upgrades and interoperability within the interchain ecosystem. The use of CLIENT_VERSION as the version parameter ensures consistency and traceability of transaction versions.


253-253: The calculation of transactionId using the encoded versioned transaction ensures that the version information is included in the transaction identifier. This approach enhances the robustness of transaction tracking and verification by incorporating version data, which is critical for distinguishing between transactions across different protocol versions.


370-379: The _assertCorrectVersion function plays a vital role in validating the version of incoming transactions. By checking against CLIENT_VERSION, it ensures that only transactions matching the current client version are processed. This version assertion mechanism is crucial for maintaining protocol compatibility and preventing the execution of transactions that are not aligned with the contract's expected version.

packages/contracts-communication/test/InterchainDB.Dst.t.sol (11)

13-14: The introduction of InterchainBatchLibHarness and VersionedPayloadLibHarness harnesses is a good practice for isolating and testing the functionality of these libraries in a controlled environment. This approach facilitates more focused and effective testing of the versioning logic.


30-31: The instantiation of InterchainBatchLibHarness and VersionedPayloadLibHarness as public variables allows for easy access and manipulation in test cases. This setup is appropriate for testing purposes, ensuring that the harnesses can be utilized across different test scenarios within this file.


46-47: Instantiating the harnesses within the setUp function is a standard practice in testing. It ensures that each test starts with a fresh instance of the necessary components, thereby avoiding unintended side effects from previous tests. This setup contributes to the reliability and independence of the tests.


51-57: The use of getVersionedBatch in the setUp function to prepare versioned batches for verification tests is a key step in setting up a comprehensive test environment. This approach ensures that the tests accurately reflect the handling of versioned data, which is critical for validating the system's behavior in real-world scenarios.


60-61: The getVersionedBatch function encapsulates the logic for encoding a InterchainBatch into a versioned payload using the VersionedPayloadLibHarness. This function is a key component of the test setup, enabling the simulation of versioned batch processing. The use of a harness for encoding ensures that the versioning logic can be tested in isolation, which is beneficial for identifying and addressing issues specific to version encoding.


64-66: The verifyBatch function, which now operates on versioned batches, is crucial for simulating the verification process in a test environment. By incorporating versioned data, this function allows for the testing of batch verification logic under conditions that closely mimic actual operational scenarios, ensuring the robustness and accuracy of the verification process.


171-172: The adjustment to handle versioned batches in assertCorrectInitialVerificationTime and other test helper functions is an important update that aligns the test logic with the introduction of versioning. This change ensures that the tests accurately assess the system's behavior when processing versioned data, which is essential for validating the integrity and functionality of the versioning mechanism.


235-237: The test case test_verifyBatch_new_emitsEvent correctly simulates the verification of a new versioned batch, expecting an event to be emitted. This test is essential for ensuring that the system behaves as expected when processing new versioned batches, including the correct emission of events to signal successful verification.


325-327: The test case test_verifyBatch_revert_conflict_sameModule effectively simulates a scenario where a versioned batch conflicts with an existing batch verified by the same module, expecting a revert. This test ensures that the system correctly handles conflicts between versioned batches, maintaining data integrity and preventing inconsistent state.


333-335: The test case test_verifyBatch_revert_sameChainId checks for the correct handling of an attempt to verify a batch originating from the same chain, expecting a revert. This test ensures that the system adheres to the intended behavior of disallowing self-referential batch verification, which is crucial for maintaining the integrity of interchain communication.


341-342: The test case test_verifyBatch_revert_wrongVersion is designed to simulate the verification of a batch with an incorrect version, expecting a revert. This test is critical for ensuring that the system robustly enforces version compatibility, rejecting batches that do not match the expected version. This behavior is essential for maintaining protocol integrity and preventing the processing of incompatible or potentially malicious data.

packages/contracts-communication/test/InterchainDB.Src.t.sol (3)

14-15: The addition of InterchainBatchLibHarness and VersionedPayloadLibHarness imports aligns with the PR's objective to streamline versioning functionalities. Ensure that these harnesses are properly implemented and tested as they play a crucial role in encoding and decoding versioned payloads and batches.


35-43: > 📝 NOTE

This review was outside the diff hunks and was mapped to the diff hunk with the greatest overlap. Original lines [38-61]

The instantiation of batchLibHarness and payloadLibHarness within the setUp function is correctly implemented. This setup is essential for testing the encoding and decoding functionalities of versioned payloads and batches using the newly integrated VersionedPayloadLib. It's important to ensure that these harnesses mimic the behavior of their production counterparts accurately for effective testing.


103-109: The modifications to getModuleCalldata to utilize payloadLibHarness and batchLibHarness for encoding versioned payloads and batches are in line with the PR's objectives. It's crucial to verify that the encoded data meets the expected format and is compatible with the decoding process on the receiving end. Additionally, comprehensive testing of this functionality, including edge cases, will ensure robustness and prevent potential issues in production.

packages/contracts-communication/test/InterchainClientV1.Dst.t.sol (16)

176-176: The executeTransaction function has been refactored to take encodedTx directly, which is a positive change for code clarity and efficiency. However, it's crucial to ensure that all tests correctly pass the encodedTx parameter and that it is properly constructed before being passed to this function.


212-213: The refactoring of test functions to retrieve encodedTx before calling executeTransaction enhances readability and maintainability. This change aligns with the PR's objective of streamlining versioning functionalities. Ensure that encodedTx is correctly encoded in all test cases where this pattern is applied.


227-229: The usage of encodedTx in the checkHappyPathScenario function demonstrates the improved approach to handling transactions. It's important to verify that encodedTx is correctly encoded and that the executeTransaction function is called with the appropriate parameters in all scenarios.


283-289: > 📝 NOTE

This review was outside the diff hunks and was mapped to the diff hunk with the greatest overlap. Original lines [286-308]

In the checkNotEnoughConfirmationsA and checkNotEnoughConfirmationsAB functions, the pattern of preparing a transaction, checking its executability, and then attempting execution is correctly followed. However, ensure that the logic for determining the number of required confirmations and the actual confirmations received is accurately implemented in these scenarios.


787-789: The test test_interchainExecute_revert_srcChainNotRemote correctly simulates a scenario where the source chain ID is incorrectly set to the local chain ID. This is a good practice for testing edge cases and ensuring robust error handling in the contract.


796-798: Similarly, the test_interchainExecute_revert_srcChainNotLinked test case ensures that the contract correctly handles scenarios where the source chain is not linked. This is crucial for maintaining the integrity of interchain transactions.


805-807: The test_interchainExecute_revert_dstChainIncorrect test case checks for incorrect destination chain IDs, which is essential for preventing transactions from being executed on unintended chains. This test reinforces the contract's security by validating chain ID checks.


812-816: The test_interchainExecute_revert_emptyOptions test case addresses the scenario of executing a transaction with empty options. It's important to ensure that the contract can handle such cases gracefully, potentially by reverting with a meaningful error message.


821-824: The test_interchainExecute_revert_invalidOptionsV0 test case is crucial for ensuring that transactions with invalid options (incorrect version) are not executed. This helps maintain the integrity of the versioning system in the contract.


829-833: The test_interchainExecute_revert_invalidOptionsV1 test case similarly checks for transactions with invalid options but focuses on a different version. This thorough testing of versioning is important for the contract's versioning logic.


839-841: The test_interchainExecute_revert_alreadyExecuted test case ensures that the contract prevents the execution of transactions that have already been executed. This is a critical security measure to prevent duplicate transactions.


852-856: The test_interchainExecute_revert_withAirdrop_zeroMsgValue test case checks the contract's handling of transactions with an airdrop option but a zero message value. This test is important for ensuring that the contract enforces the correct airdrop requirements.


867-871: The test_interchainExecute_revert_withAirdrop_lowerMsgValue test case is crucial for verifying that the contract correctly handles cases where the message value is lower than required for the airdrop. This ensures that the airdrop logic is strictly enforced.


882-886: The test_interchainExecute_revert_withAirdrop_higherMsgValue test case ensures that the contract can handle cases where the message value is higher than required for the airdrop. While not a critical issue, it's good to test for overpayment scenarios.


897-900: The test_interchainExecute_revert_noAirdrop_nonZeroMsgValue test case checks for scenarios where a transaction without an airdrop option is executed with a non-zero message value. This test ensures that the contract correctly handles message value discrepancies.


913-915: The test_interchainExecute_revert_zeroRequiredResponses test case is important for ensuring that the contract does not allow transactions with zero required responses. This test helps maintain the integrity of the response verification process.

@ChiTimesChi ChiTimesChi merged commit 269fcde into feat/interchain-versioning-library Mar 31, 2024
36 checks passed
@ChiTimesChi ChiTimesChi deleted the feat/interchain-versioning-deduplicate-libraries branch March 31, 2024 12:40
ChiTimesChi added a commit that referenced this pull request Apr 4, 2024
* Scaffold `VersionedPayload` library

* Implement basic encode/decode

* Implement decoding in memory

* Update Options versioning

* Update AppConfig versioning

* Use new version getter in Execution Service

* Fix: decodeOptions is now view

* Update tests

* Regenerate `sin-executor`

* Additional tests to mimic real usage

* feat(contracts-communication): Interchain versioning for batches (#2390)

* Implement Batch versioning

* Scaffold versioned batch verification

* Update tests with expected behavior for versioned batches

* Complete versioned batch verification

* feat(contracts-communication): Interchain versioning for transactions (#2393)

* Implement Transaction versioning

* Implement tests for versioned txs

* Adjust integration tests

* Implement client/tx versioning

* Chore: cleanup deprecated functions

* Chore: remove unused imports

* Chore: `forge fmt`

* fix(contracts-communication): deduplicate versioning libraries (#2402)

* Bring back the vanilla encoding/decoding funcs

* Deduplicate Batch library

* Update DB and Module to use generic library

* Update tests

* Deduplicate Transaction library

* Update Client to use generic library

* Update tests

* Adjust `verifyRemoteBatch` mock for Go tests

* Regenerate `sin-executor`

* Fix Go test

* Regenerate `committee`
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Labels
Projects
None yet
Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

1 participant