Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

The name 'Torsion' is not ideal #20

Closed
special opened this issue Mar 28, 2014 · 22 comments
Closed

The name 'Torsion' is not ideal #20

special opened this issue Mar 28, 2014 · 22 comments
Milestone

Comments

@special
Copy link
Member

special commented Mar 28, 2014

The name 'torsion' was chosen at random some years ago, and has three major problems:

  • It vaguely implies a relationship to Tor that doesn't exist, when it should be clearly independent
  • There is an unpleasant association with a testicular condition
  • It's not very searchable

If a better name can be chosen, it would be good to change this as soon as possible.

@special
Copy link
Member Author

special commented Mar 28, 2014

Suggestions welcome. origami was mentioned courtesy of armadev.

@glamrock
Copy link

Origami is cool =)

@special
Copy link
Member Author

special commented Mar 28, 2014

tim (or tIM, no acronym implied) is another option. It is also not searchable, but avoids the other two problems. URIs would change too: origami:rs7ce36jsj24ogfw or tim:rs7ce36jsj24ogfw.

It's also worth thinking about how someone who hasn't learned about the software will discover how to handle one of these IDs when they're encountered. Search-ability may be very important. Or maybe the URIs should contain some other keyword or domain name that a person could look up.

@Antaon
Copy link

Antaon commented Mar 29, 2014

origoim - Two sylibles: Or-EE go-im (Oreo minus the o at the end and "go im" rhymes with "go in")
Rememberable: Or I go IM
Uniquely searchable: "origoim" has very few search results, so it would be easy to become the main result.
Domain name origoim.net is available.

@special special added this to the 1.0.x milestone Mar 29, 2014
@glamrock
Copy link

What about Guten Tag? Like Bonjour, only more German ;-)

@special
Copy link
Member Author

special commented Mar 29, 2014

nameless

orveil is an interesting one. It brings to mind orwell and surveil, concealment, and stands for onion-routed

@adrelanos
Copy link

A name that yields no search results on google is imho ideal, imho.

  • no competition with other search terms
  • no trademark issues
  • all discussions about $project_name can be found when searching for $project_name

@dioxx
Copy link

dioxx commented Apr 16, 2014

i was thinking last night and i have an idea:

cantor. That's mean a can+tor. The idea of a can came to my childhood, where we do a telephone with two cans and a wire and only we can ear what was said. Even the symbol will be easy to do, like to cans united by i wire or two onions instead of cans.

it's just an idea, but i think have to do with the software.

@stnkris
Copy link

stnkris commented Apr 16, 2014

FULL DISCLORE I am not a developer of this project just chiming in with my two cents.

I like the idea behind cantor but it's not easily searchable, and it has the same problem of implying relation with Tor.

An idea I had for a similar project I work on (using Tor just not a fork of Torchat and written in Node-Webkit) was called Keystalk with the idea of being "Keys Talk" or like beanstalk (for logo or branding) I would be fine with giving that name away and surrendering any usage of it if people want to use that. It's google hits are low and unrelated (Black Eyed peas or some crap)

EDIT Also forgot to mention it can also be "Key Stalk" which is a way to relate to a user someone who might be stalking your public key.

@hsribei
Copy link
Contributor

hsribei commented Apr 16, 2014

IMHO the name doesn't have to be unique to be searchable. As long as it is unique in the "namespace" of apps or of chat apps, it's fine. People would search for <name> chat or <name> app.

I like origami. Some other random names that come to mind:

Ricochet
Brownian

Ok, I might come up with more later :) Congrats on the great project, btw!

@adrelanos
Copy link

The name "Whonix" was suggested on the tor-talk mailing list. Might be a
good idea to ask for name suggestions there.

@special
Copy link
Member Author

special commented Apr 17, 2014

Thanks for all of the suggestions! It's a difficult decision.

@dioxx's cantor was a good idea, but the connection with Tor makes it unusable. @stnkris's keystalk is nice too, but it reads as stalk, which seems like the wrong association to make.

I'm currently liking origami and ricochet. Neither is uniquely searchable, but @obvio171 has a decent point about that. They're nice to say, and can be made more descriptive with something like Origami IM where it's needed.

route was also mentioned by someone. It's a little hard to build off of, but Route IM and route:rs7ce36jsj24ogfw aren't bad.

I seem to have a bias towards good pronunciations. Hmm.

@special special modified the milestones: 1.0.2, 1.0.x Apr 17, 2014
@majestrate
Copy link

How about Chattor? It's a combination of chat+tor and a variant on chatter.

@dioxx
Copy link

dioxx commented May 20, 2014

days ago i had an idea: how about Whisper?

@bookie988
Copy link

whispersystems.org
TorTalk (its got nothing to do with tor, neither does torchat, still using it)
Date: Mon, 19 May 2014 22:56:04 -0700
From: notifications@github.com
To: torsion@noreply.github.com
Subject: Re: [torsion] The name 'Torsion' is not ideal (#20)

days ago i had an idea: how about Whisper?


Reply to this email directly or view it on GitHub.

@special
Copy link
Member Author

special commented Jun 20, 2014

Thanks for all of the suggestions (and sorry it took so long!). I decided on Ricochet, which is unique among instant messaging applications, and I like the sound of it.

Github and Transifex are renamed. ricochet.im is the new URL, with SSL and hopefully a proper landing page coming soon. Old configurations and addresses will keep working, but as of the next release addresses will start with ricochet:.

Updated binaries coming soon.

@special special closed this as completed Jun 20, 2014
@DomT4
Copy link

DomT4 commented Jun 20, 2014

Just a heads up that your SSL cert gets a great big red/yellow flag on Firefox & Chrome because of the self-signing. Namecheap do pretty decently priced SSL certs if you're looking for one.

@stnkris
Copy link

stnkris commented Jun 20, 2014

Namecheap also takes Bitcoin, so in theory we could all pay for it.

@hsribei
Copy link
Contributor

hsribei commented Jun 27, 2014

Awesome! @special would it be ok for me to have attribution for coming up with the name on whichever form of about/contributors/authors/readme file/menu you decide on please? I'm very happy and proud that I could make a contribution :)

@special
Copy link
Member Author

special commented Jul 6, 2014

@DomT4 yep, I'm waiting on a response for something. If that doesn't work out, I'll buy one. Will be fixed soon.

@obvio171 Absolutely! You're in AUTHORS.md and the 1.0.2 changelog

@hsribei
Copy link
Contributor

hsribei commented Jul 7, 2014

\o/

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Labels
None yet
Projects
None yet
Development

No branches or pull requests

11 participants