-
Notifications
You must be signed in to change notification settings - Fork 869
New issue
Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.
By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.
Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account
Unique fast-food names #6071
Unique fast-food names #6071
Conversation
You can add |
Thank you for your answer @kjonosm.
Just like for example McDoanld's are usually at least open The same could be said about the website. Having the brand website on |
I agree with @kjonosm on this one: I believe it's better to have a name than no name at all for these fast food brands. For Five Guys, although the website shows they have the branch in their name, they're usually signed as just "Five Guys". If the French community prefers local names like the Norwegian/Swedish community, these brands should probably get their own entry restricted to just France. |
Thank you for your answer too @arch0345 !
Isn't that why brand=* exist ? Any consumer (e.g. like OSMAnd, JOSM do) can use it in lieu of name=* if it's not available. But suggesting/forcing to put an incomplete/incorrect name just to put a name seems counter-productive for the OSM database.
If the shop chooses to use a specific name in its communication with patrons, why should we (OSM contributors) choose otherwise ? |
Oh yeah, I'm just seeing this now, @gileri please don't go deleting the We should publish some better guidance about how this project handles names, but the tl;dr today is:
|
I thought that bringing accurate data was a goal of name-suggestion-index, that quality was more important than quantity. Thank you for clarifying the position of the project. I'll guess I'll have to continue fixing incorrect names caused by NSI instead of making more meaningful contributions to OSM. |
Thank you for sharing this data @tas50. As you can see by the 7 links I shared, the restaurants have a unique, public-facing name. I think the information on the franchise-owned websites is more authoritative on the subject than Google Maps or Apple Maps. |
I'm not going strictly off Apple Maps or Google maps although both of those are very useful since the brands themselves generally choose how to be represented there. I'm going off personal experience going to 3 different Five Guys near me and 1 in another state. There's no mention of which store it is anywhere. They're just Five Guys. |
Following my last PR, I suggest the same adjustement for other franchises : Do not suggest incomplete names for franchises with unique, public-facing names. That will allow users to fill out the correct name using various editors such as iD, or StreetComplete.
Fast Foods
Bagel Corner
bagelcorner-e4dee6
https://restaurants.bagelcorner.fr/
bigfernand-8ddd61
https://bigfernand.com/restaurants/
exki-a3472e
https://www.exki.com/restaurants
fiveguys-200282
https://restaurants.fiveguys.com/pa/allentown
https://restaurants.fiveguys.fr/
https://www.societe.com/etablissement/five-guys-81751824400287.html
https://restaurants.fiveguys.be/en_be
https://restaurants.fiveguys.ae/en_ae
https://restaurants.fiveguys.ca/ab/calgary
https://restaurants.fiveguys.de/
https://restaurantes.fiveguys.es/index.html
[...]
flowerburger-777b0e
https://www.flowerburger.it/negozi/flower-burger-milano-garibaldi/
https://www.flowerburger.fr/stores/flower-burger-marseille/
laboiteapizza-e4dee6
https://www.laboiteapizza.com/landing/
lacroissanterie-7eae30
https://www.lacroissanterie.fr/trouver-restaurant/store/12/ANGOULEME%201%20(LA%20COURONNE)
malvon-d3d66f
https://www.malvon.es/tiendas
pommedepain-508db0
https://pommedepain.fr/restaurant/croixrault/
https://pommedepain.fr/restaurant/grombalia/
pretamanger-027ef2
Only US have purely address based "names". Other places have either unique names, or just 1 locations at the moment.
https://locations.pretamanger.fr/paris/place-louis-armand
https://www.pret.hk/en-HK/find-a-pret
https://www.pret.co.uk/en-GB/shop-finder
quick-9fdafe
https://www.quick.fr/aulnay-cc
https://www.quick.lu/fr/restaurant/kirchberg
https://www.quick.be/fr/restaurant/gare-du-midi
sushishop-ac545e
https://www.sushishop.fr/fr/restaurants
https://www.sushiart.ae/en/restaurants
https://www.sushishop.be/fr/restaurants
https://www.mysushishop.ch/fr/restaurants
https://www.sushishop.eu/