-
Notifications
You must be signed in to change notification settings - Fork 822
New issue
Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.
By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.
Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account
A service highway is not displayed while a track is #2092
Comments
sent from a phone
I would see this as a very probable tagging error (a service that is only connected to tracks is very likely itself a track), but I agree that the way should be rendered at this zoom level nonetheless |
Well, I was there yesterday and it really is a service - it is wide enough for two cars to pass by. The road is used by forest management for transporting cut trees, regular traffic is not allowed there. |
sent from a phone
sounds like a perfect track to me |
@PontiacCZ I suspect that this is related to one of the changes made around the same time as #747 (though not actually that change; this is a service=driveway and it's that tag that causes it not to appear). The problem is that many service=driveway are quite short and occur quite close together (in urban areas). The rendering is the same for everywhere in the world (a driveway in the middle of Antarctica will get rendered the same at the same zoom level as one in the middle of New York City), and it's simply not possible with the "standard" style as it is now to optimise it for everywhere. That said, as @dieterdreist suggests about are you sure it's tagged correctly? Although the original versions are redacted it looks like it might have been a "highway=track; surface=paved; tracktype=grade1" at some point. Even if "highway=service" is correct is it really a driveway? Your description sounds like it may not be. |
You are right about it not being driveway. That is nonsense here. I removed the service=driveway tag and the service renders now. |
So it can be a highway=service, but it probably shouldn't be tagged service=driveway. |
So it is highway=track. It is highly confusing but highway=track is not about quality - unpaved residential road is not highway=track, high quality asphalt road used solely for forest management/field access is highway=track. Also duplicate of #561 Given that this case is a clear tagging error (especially service=driveway) this is not a good example of rendering problem. |
Subject area: http://www.openstreetmap.org/?mlat=49.08807&mlon=17.11303&zoom=12#map=15/49.1089/17.0781
As you can see, in zoom 15 (and less) the service highway is not displayed.
When you zoom into zoom 16, it finally shows up.
Highway=service is typically broader and more important that a highway=track so I suppose if something was to be ignored it should be a track, not a service way.
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: