You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
I have two issues which could be solved with this idea:
a. For each tree I add, I have to do a lot of clicks to specify leaf_type and leaf_cycle. That is very tedious, especially since in my region both have a relation in nearly all cases (as in "nearly all trees which are broadleaved are also deciduous, nearly all trees which are needleleaved are also evergreen").
b. I nearly never tag the type/genus, because I need to look up the correct spelling to not mess up the database. Even though in quite some cases I could at least specify the broader genus (as in, I know that a tree is a genus:de=Eiche (EN: Oak), but I would not know that it is a species:de=Stieleiche).
This would also solve different spelling like "oak" (taginfo:43), "Oak" (taginfo:15), "en:Oak" (taginfo:2)
My suggestion:
Add name suggestion for some commonly used trees.
Commonly could be defined as "all that have been tagged > 1000"
I think iD is probably a better place for this, since it would be a curated list of the most common tree presets - name_suggestion_index is really for things with names.
I've put my thoughts on tree presets here: openstreetmap/iD#4240 and I'm reluctant to take this up right now. (please add your comments to that issue instead of opening a new one).
If it's really true that we could make the tree presets usable for untrained users, then I would be ok with it.
I have two issues which could be solved with this idea:
a. For each tree I add, I have to do a lot of clicks to specify
leaf_type
andleaf_cycle
. That is very tedious, especially since in my region both have a relation in nearly all cases (as in "nearly all trees which are broadleaved are also deciduous, nearly all trees which are needleleaved are also evergreen").b. I nearly never tag the type/genus, because I need to look up the correct spelling to not mess up the database. Even though in quite some cases I could at least specify the broader genus (as in, I know that a tree is a
genus:de=Eiche
(EN: Oak), but I would not know that it is aspecies:de=Stieleiche
).This would also solve different spelling like "oak" (taginfo:43), "Oak" (taginfo:15), "en:Oak" (taginfo:2)
My suggestion:
Add name suggestion for some commonly used trees.
Commonly could be defined as "all that have been tagged > 1000"
Example
Suggestion name EN:
Tree: Oak tree
Suggestion name DE:
Baum: Eiche
Tags:
Suggestion name EN:
Tree: Picea tree
Suggestion name DE:
Baum: Fichte
Tags:
Wiki pages about trees:
Would this name-suggestion-index be the right place for this idea?
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: