Community Review of FILWALLET #189
Comments
|
Allocator Application 1. Digital Earth Africa #3 The data proposed by the client was stored on filecoin many times. A few examples: The above examples contain different datasets for DE Africa, however it is unknown which ones were used by the client in question as the allocator did not ask any additional questions. SPs provided: SPs used for deals: Only 2 SPs match the list provided by the customer. The original list contained 6 SPs, the actual list contains 14. In allocator's application it was said that Allocator will require 3 different regions from clients. SPs provided by client were in one region and allocator did not respond. Actual SPs provided by client are from different regions but looking at this application it looks like a lucky coincidence. Please correct me if I am wrong. 11 of 13 SPs have a retrieval rate of 0 or unavailable. Lastly, according to the allocator application, the first tranche should be 5% of the total DC, but in this client's case, it was 10%. Why this inconsistency? 2. LAMOST DR7 #14 This client attempted to get a DC for the same dataset from a different allocator. While this is not the subject of this review, this client still requested a DC renewal from a different allocator on October 8 in the comment, while the application in question is from September. A dataset with this name was stored on filecoin multiple times. Although these may be different datasets, the client should prove their uniqueness, which was not the case. Has the allocator questioned this? 3. NOAA SPs list used for deals: No SP matches the provided list. This dataset was stored many times. NOAA often appears as a dataset in applications, so you need to pay special attention to applications that use these datasets. Below is a link to search just for this dataset. There are 10 search results. https://github.com/search?q=repo%3Afilecoin-project%2Ffilecoin-plus-large-datasets+noaa-gefs-reforecast&type=issues With allocator.tech, you can find applications open on 12 other allocators by typing in NOAA's name. Did the allocator ensure that sending more copies of the dataset would be valuable for the network? |
Notary Public Application Form: filecoin-project/notary-governance#1044
Compliance report: https://compliance.allocator.tech/report/f03013312/1728609650/report.md
Customer 1: a1991car/Allocator-Public-Data#3
Customer 2: a1991car/Allocator-Public-Data#14
Customer 3: a1991car/Allocator-Public-Data#16
Our 5PiB has been used up and we hope to be able to recharge in the next round.
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: